You might think all payroll providers are created equally, and if that’s you, then you are wrong.
It can be tempting to simply look for the lowest possible price available, and for sure, there are some great deals to be had out there, but you also need to consider the high cost of low prices.
For example, if you’re paying too low a price, then the chances are that the provider won’t have specialist knowledge in house about payroll legislation and regulations.
Equally important is understanding the services, customer service, security and their wider knowledge and expertise of the provider.
So how can you slice through the noise and work out if you’ve a great payroll provider or if they’re a dud that you should avoid? You use the Go Impartial list of questions to ask a potential payroll provider of course!
We’ve broken this guide down into different categories so you can pick and choose the questions that are right for your situation.
Let’s get into it.
Services Offered
These questions will help you understand the full scope of what they can provide, as well as how their services align with your company’s needs. This is important because not all payroll providers offer the same range of services, and you want to make sure you choose a provider that can meet your specific requirements.
Some of the services you might want to look out for include tax filing, employee benefits, direct deposit, and employee self-service portals. These services can help make the payroll process more efficient and can provide additional value to both your company and your employees.
Essential services that you should expect to hear about from a payroll provider include payroll processing, tax filing, and direct deposit. These services are typically considered the core offering of a payroll provider and are necessary for most businesses. Optional services, such as employee benefits or self-service portals, can be useful for some companies, but are not essential for all.
Other optional services that a payroll provider may offer include employee onboarding and offboarding support, direct deposit, and time tracking. These services can provide additional convenience and support for your business, but they may also come at an additional cost.
These questions are helpful to understand their services:
- What services do you offer as part of your payroll processing package?
- Do you offer any additional services, such as tax filing or compliance support?
- Can you provide a detailed breakdown of the services included in your payroll processing package?
- Do you offer employee onboarding and offboarding support?
- Do you offer direct deposit as part of your payroll processing service?
- Do you offer time tracking or attendance tracking as part of your payroll processing service?
- Are there any additional services that you offer for an additional cost?
Knowledge and Expertise
Asking about a potential payroll provider’s knowledge and expertise can be important for several reasons. First, having a knowledgeable and experienced provider can help to ensure that your payroll is processed accurately and efficiently. This can help to avoid any errors or mistakes that could result in incorrect payments or penalties from tax authorities.
Additionally, having a knowledgeable and experienced provider can also provide valuable guidance and support when it comes to compliance with relevant laws and regulations. This can help to ensure that your small business stays in compliance with all applicable rules and requirements, which can help to avoid potential fines or other penalties.
Furthermore, a knowledgeable and experienced provider can also be a valuable resource for your small business when it comes to navigating the complexities of payroll processing and tax filing. They can provide valuable insights and advice that can help your business to grow and thrive.
Ask these questions about the payroll providers’ knowledge and experience:
- How long have you been providing payroll services in the UK?
- What qualifications or certifications do you have related to payroll processing in the UK?
- Can you provide examples of complex payroll situations that you have successfully managed in the UK?
- Do you stay up-to-date on changes to UK payroll laws and regulations? How do you ensure compliance with these changes?
- Can you provide references from other UK small business owners who have used your services and can speak to your knowledge and expertise?
- Do you offer any additional support or guidance to UK small businesses when it comes to payroll processing and tax filing?
- Are you able to provide custom solutions for UK small businesses with unique payroll needs?
- Do you have any specialised knowledge or expertise in areas such as payroll for international employees, or other complex situations relevant to the UK?
Find your Next Professional Now!
Software Used
Understanding the software that they use can help you to understand the capabilities and features of their payroll processing service. This can be helpful in determining whether the provider offers the functionality and support that your business needs.
In terms of likely options for payroll software, there are several different options that a provider may use. Some common examples include dedicated payroll software, such as Sage, Brightpay, KeyPay, or even Xero & QuickBooks. In some cases, a provider may also develop their own proprietary software for payroll processing.
Different software packages can have different features and capabilities, which can impact your business in different ways. For example, some software packages may offer more advanced features for managing employee benefits or tracking time and attendance, while others may have more basic functionality. Additionally, some software packages may be more user-friendly or easier to use, which can be helpful for small business owners who are not familiar with payroll processing.
Whether you will need to see or use the payroll software will depend on the specific arrangements that you have with your payroll provider. In some cases, you may be able to access the software directly and manage your payroll yourself, while in other cases the provider may handle all aspects of payroll processing on your behalf.
If you are able to access the software directly, you may need to use it to provide employee information, such as hours worked or benefits deductions, or to review and approve payroll reports and other documents. In this case, it can be helpful to choose a software package that is user-friendly and easy to use.
If your provider handles all aspects of payroll processing on your behalf, you may not need to see or use the software at all. In this case, it can be helpful to choose a provider that offers a high level of customer service and support, so that you can easily get answers to any questions or concerns that you may have.
These are the sort of questions you should ask on this front:
- What software do you use for payroll processing?
- Will I have direct access to the software, or will you handle all aspects of payroll processing on my behalf?
- Can you provide a demonstration of the software and its features?
- Are there any features of the software that are particularly useful for small businesses, such as time tracking or employee benefits management?
- How user-friendly is the software, and is there any training or support available to help me learn how to use it?
- Will I be able to review and approve payroll reports and other documents through the software?
- How does the software support the onboarding process for new employees?
- Are there any additional fees or charges associated with using the software?
- Are there any integration or compatibility issues that I should be aware of with the software?
Customer Service
It can be important to ask a potential payroll provider about their customer service, as having access to timely and helpful support can be essential for managing your payroll effectively. For example, you may need a quick answer to a payroll question if you are dealing with a last-minute change or issue with an employee’s pay, or if you have a question about compliance with payroll laws and regulations.
In these cases, having a provider with a high level of customer service and support can be invaluable. This can help to ensure that you can get the answers and assistance that you need in a timely manner, which can help to avoid potential errors or mistakes in your payroll processing.
In terms of looking for a service level agreement, this can be a good way to ensure that you receive a certain level of customer service and support from your provider. A service level agreement typically outlines the specific services that a provider will offer, as well as the expected response times and other aspects of their customer service. Having a service level agreement in place can provide additional reassurance that your provider will be able to provide the support that your business needs.
Here are some questions you could ask a potential payroll provider to learn more about their customer service:
- How do you handle customer support and assistance?
- What are your response times for customer inquiries or requests for support?
- Do you offer any training or guidance to help small business owners learn how to use your payroll processing services?
- Can you provide examples of complex or challenging situations that you have successfully resolved for other small business customers?
- Do you offer any additional support or guidance for small businesses when it comes to compliance with payroll laws and regulations?
- Do you have a service level agreement that outlines the specific services and support that you offer?
- Can you provide references from other small business owners who have used your services and can speak to the quality of your customer service?
- Are there any additional fees or charges associated with accessing your customer service and support?
- Do you offer support in languages other than English, for small businesses with international employees?
Issue Resolution
Ask about how the payroll provider will handle issue resolution, including their experience and track record in dealing with HMRC.
Payroll audits can be a complex and time-consuming process, so it’s worth looking for a provider who has experience in this area and can help you navigate any potential issues that may arise. You may also want to consider whether the provider offers any additional services or support to help you prepare for and respond to payroll audits, such as providing guidance on record-keeping and documentation, or offering training and support for your team.
Ultimately, the goal should be to find a provider who can help you maintain compliance with all relevant laws and regulations, while also providing the support and assistance you need to effectively manage your payroll processes.
To learn more, ask them these sort of questions:
- Can you tell me about your experience and track record in dealing with HMRC and other regulatory bodies?
- What support and guidance do you offer to help businesses prepare for and respond to payroll audits?
- How do you handle errors or discrepancies that arise in payroll processing, and how do you work with clients to resolve these issues?
- Can you provide examples of how you have successfully assisted clients in dealing with HMRC or other regulatory bodies in the past?
- Do you offer any additional services or support to help businesses maintain compliance with relevant laws and regulations, such as training or guidance on record-keeping and documentation?
- Do you have a dedicated team or point of contact to handle issue resolution and support clients in dealing with HMRC or other regulatory bodies?
Reputation + Track Record
Reputation and track record are important factors to consider when selecting a payroll provider. A reputable firm is likely to have a proven track record of delivering high-quality services and successful outcomes for their clients.
They may also have a good reputation within the industry and among their clients, as evidenced by positive customer reviews and testimonials, industry awards and recognitions, and a strong presence and reputation within the marketplace.
To evaluate a provider’s reputation and track record, you could ask for references from their existing clients and speak with them directly to learn about their experiences and the outcomes they have achieved. You could also research the provider online to see what others are saying about them, and look for industry awards or recognitions they may have received.
You could ask the provider directly about their experience and track record in the industry, and any notable achievements or successes they have had. This can give you a better understanding of the provider’s reputation and track record, and can help you determine whether they are a reputable and reliable partner for your business.
It’s worth noting that all payroll providers on the Go Impartial panel have already been pre-vetted and are considered experts in their field. This means that they have demonstrated a proven track record of providing high-quality services and great customer service. They are known for offering clear and transparent pricing, with fixed costs that make it easy for businesses to budget and plan for their payroll expenses.
Choosing a provider from our panel can provide added reassurance and confidence that you are working with a reputable and reliable partner who can support your business’s needs.
To find out more about this, ask them these questions:
- Can you provide references or testimonials from existing clients who can speak to the quality of your services and the outcomes they have achieved?
- Have you received any industry awards or recognitions that speak to the excellence of your services and your reputation within the industry?
- Can you provide examples of notable achievements or successes you have had, such as helping clients achieve significant cost savings or improve their payroll processes?
- What is your overall reputation within the industry and among your clients? Can you provide any information or metrics to support this, such as customer satisfaction ratings or positive reviews?
- How long have you been in business, and what is your experience and track record in the payroll industry?
- Can you provide any additional information or evidence that can help demonstrate your reputation and track record within the industry?
Staying Compliant
It’s essential for a provider to stay up-to-date with all relevant laws and regulations, and to have systems and processes in place to ensure that they remain compliant at all times. This can help protect your business from potential fines or penalties, and can ensure that your payroll processes are efficient and accurate.
When evaluating a provider’s approach to compliance, you could ask them about the systems and processes they have in place to ensure compliance.
This could include questions such as:
- Can you tell me about your approach to compliance, and how you ensure that you remain up-to-date with all relevant laws and regulations?
- Do you have a dedicated team or resources dedicated to compliance, and what is their level of expertise and experience in this area?
- Can you provide examples of how you have successfully helped clients maintain compliance with relevant laws and regulations?
- Do you offer any additional services or support to help clients maintain compliance, such as training or guidance on record-keeping and documentation?
- Can you provide any additional information or evidence to demonstrate your commitment to compliance and your expertise in this area?
Asking these questions can give you a better understanding of the provider’s approach to compliance, and can help you determine whether they have the systems and expertise in place to help you maintain compliance with all relevant laws and regulations. This can provide added assurance and peace of mind that your business will be in good hands when it comes to compliance.
Security Practices
Security is an important consideration when selecting a payroll provider, as you want to ensure that your payroll data is protected and secure at all times. Good security practices for a payroll provider should include measures to protect against data loss, theft, and unauthorised access, as well as regular backups and disaster recovery procedures to minimise the impact of any potential security incidents.
To evaluate a provider’s security practices, you could ask them about the specific measures they have in place to protect your payroll data. This could include questions such as:
- Can you tell me about your security practices and the measures you have in place to protect against data loss, theft, and unauthorised access?
- Do you have regular backups and disaster recovery procedures in place, and how do you ensure that your systems and data are secure in the event of a security incident?
- Are your systems and data encrypted, and do you have any additional measures in place to protect sensitive information?
- Can you provide any additional information or evidence to demonstrate your commitment to security and the measures you have in place to protect your clients’ data?
- Do you have any certifications or accreditations that demonstrate your commitment to security and best practices in this area?
Asking these questions can give you a better understanding of the provider’s security practices, and can help you determine whether they have the systems and expertise in place to protect your payroll data. Additionally, you can look for providers who have any relevant certifications or accreditations, such as ISO 27001 certification for information security management, which can provide added assurance of their commitment to security.
Find your next accountant now!
Cost of Services
When it comes to cost and pricing, it’s important to find a payroll provider who offers competitive and transparent pricing that aligns with the value and level of service they provide. Payroll providers may offer different pricing models, but many base their pricing on the number of employees or the specific services and features included in their plans.
To evaluate a provider’s pricing and cost structure, you could ask them about the specific details of their pricing plans, including the services and features included and any additional costs or fees that may apply. You could also ask about any discounts or promotions they may have available, and whether their pricing is fixed or subject to change. Additionally, you could ask about the pricing of any additional services or support they may offer, such as assistance with payroll audits or compliance.
Asking these questions can help you understand the provider’s pricing structure and the value they offer, and can help you compare their prices to those of other providers to determine the best fit for your business. Ultimately, the goal should be to find a provider who offers competitive pricing and a good value for the services and support they provide.
And if you’re ready for a free consultation with a payroll provider, then book one with us now.